dhodo
Well-Known Member
Where? Classics and Essentials will be soul in the same month?
Vinyl Me Please Essentials
- Thread starter Captainfog
- Start date
NathanRicaud
Well-Known Member
Ohhhh my bad! I got the Classics and Essentials clue mixed up for the December ROTM!
NathanRicaud
Well-Known Member
I hope the December Essentials ROTM actually does end up being Jill Scott's Who Is Jill Scott? because the 2020 reissue sucks! It skips and has a lot of surface noise! 
MikeH
Well-Known Member
The word “features” is the confusing part to me. I wouldn’t say Stankonia “features Andre 3000”...hes one of 2 main people on it. but we all know that even though Storf is the editor, he hardly has a way with words...The way the hint is phrased, the 2nd album would have to be Badu In this case. It doesn’t matter that Badu was on Stankonia because that’s not any part of the clue. And as far as I know, Andre was never on any Erykah Badu tracks until But You Cain’t. So she isn’t the first ROTM...
All I really know is that it’s not often that everyone guesses the right albums within a few hours of a first vague clue and more often than not it leads to disappointment for those that can’t talk themselves into loving some album they never wanted prior to it being a ROTM hah
NathanRicaud
Well-Known Member
ATLiens, Aquemini, Stankonia, Baduizm & Mama's Gun are all wonderful albums! They are incredible albums and all deserve the Essentials treatment! Baby monster is going to be super happy if the Essentials picks for the next few months really are OutKast and Erykah Badu! That's the music I loved when I was young, in school and still play and love. I have all those albums on vinyl but want it them to get the VMP Essentials treatment!
bettim84
Well-Known Member
It looks like we’re going to disagree on this one. FWIW I’m a big Nirvana fan. But I do think Live Through This is essential.
NathanRicaud
Well-Known Member
No thanks! I definitely hope it isn't that!
No chance VMP would make Cher an Essentials ROTM!
MikeH
Well-Known Member
I agree they all deserve it. I’m a huge Badu fan as well as Outkast and would gladly upgrade. I just don’t want people to get their hopes up like they do every month and have it end up being Avril Lavigne and Nickleback or something like that hah
also why does everyone say VMP pretty much promised Stankonia? I know people have talked about it for awhile but can’t remember why that rumor started outside of people thinking it because it’s the 20th anniversary and they have done Outkast before? And it seems like Sir Lucious Left foot is the RHH for one of these 3 months too right?
bettim84
Well-Known Member
No thanks! I definitely hope it isn't that!
No chance VMP would make Cher an Essentials ROTM!
You guys keep forgetting the “featured” clue. It’s unlikely the artists will be “Ex #1” and “Ex #2.”
Instead it’ll be more likely “album that features a brief appearance by Ex #1” and then “Ex #2.”
You know VMP won’t do a Cher album, so your next best move is to search for guest appearances by Cher on other artists’ albums. And so on.
NathanRicaud
Well-Known Member
OutKast & Erykah Badu confirmed! Very likely that OutKast will be October, and Lauryn Hill will be December too, with November being unrelated to those two picks/clue!
MikeH
Well-Known Member
Also @NathanRicaud its a bummer to hear the Jill Scott reissue sucks...you and I have both put Who is Jill Scott? atop our VMP wishlists for awhile. I have an OG pressing but it could definitely use a good update/remaster/repress.
McGlam
Well-Known Member
I remember there being very strong hinting from Storf that Outkast would be an essential pick this fall, I don't remember why Stankonia specifically but there was a reason. I would suspect that there would be a mention of a tie-in with RHH if Big Boi were going to be a pick though. I really hope we get Mama's Gun, that's the only Badu I'm missing!
NathanRicaud
Well-Known Member
I know Mike! Who Is Jill Scott? is one of my favourite albums of the 2000's and I was so disappointed by the reissue! Gutted! And yeah, you know how much I love that album too as I use to post it in the VMP Wishlist back in the VMP forum!
The pressing is noisy, sound quality is average and there's skipping! And if you look on Discogs, this 2020 reissue also has poor reviews...Totally gutted!
NathanRicaud
Well-Known Member
The pressing for Mama's Gun sounds pretty great but I want it to get the VMP treatment still because that's my favourite Badu album! I love Baduizm so much though and the pressing for that album is good, but not as good as Mama's Gun! Either pick will be a total winner!
But looking closely at the clue, I feel like we won't be getting Erykah Badu unfortunately. I think Storf is only talking about the October and December Essentials pick in that clue! Unless he really is saying the ex spouse of the October pick is the November Essentials pick! I dunno, but either way, I am so excited to see what the Essential picks are!
MikeH
Well-Known Member
It’s the 20th anniversary of Stankonia in October is probably why people think it could be that
dhodo
Well-Known Member
I remember him saying specifically that's the one they would do for essentials and hinting it would happen. I remember because I would pick Aquemini personally and he kinda said it like, of course Stankonia is the more essential one, which I disagree with. Pretty sure it was on the VMP forum.
NathanRicaud
Well-Known Member
I think both are as Essential as each other, but if I had to choose between Aquemini and Stankonia, I'd pick Stankonia! It's just a groundbreaking album that pushed the boundaries of hip-hop and the singles on that album are just...
dhodo
Well-Known Member
I think for me, while the singles are great on Stankonia, I prefer Aquemini as a whole album. No shade on Stankonia, it is a truly great album. I am perfectly happy with my original Aquemini and I haven't heard anything good about the original Stankonia press, so at this point I'd rather they do it too, since I need that one still.I think both are as Essential as each other, but if I had to choose between Aquemini and Stankonia, I'd pick Stankonia! It's just a groundbreaking album that pushed the boundaries of hip-hop and the singles on that album are just...
Did you see that Stankonia article I shared in the hip hop thread today? Good piece if anyone here doesn't frequent over there, since we keep talking about it here.
20/20 Vision: Outkast — Stankonia
20/20 Vision returns as Son Raw thoroughly revisits one of rap’s all-time great albums.
NathanRicaud
Well-Known Member
Yeah, the Aquemini pressing sounds great, and the MOV pressing for Stankonia is great and is definitely better than the original pressing (which I purchased when I first started collecting vinyl)!I think for me, while the singles are great on Stankonia, I prefer Aquemini as a whole album. No shade on Stankonia, it is a truly great album. I am perfectly happy with my original Aquemini and I haven't heard anything good about the original Stankonia press, so at this point I'd rather they do it too, since I need that one still.
Did you see that Stankonia article I shared in the hip hop thread today? Good piece if anyone here doesn't frequent over there, since we keep talking about it here.
20/20 Vision: Outkast — Stankonia
20/20 Vision returns as Son Raw thoroughly revisits one of rap’s all-time great albums.www.passionweiss.com
Thanks for the link to that! I didn't see it and am gonna give it a read!
