Anabelle wasn't even on my radar, tbh. I've been keeping my dreamies list pretty concise, but three times now I've settled for alternatives because after 40–50 islands I'm ready to throw my Switch in the trash.
Muffy was my first settle, and she's who just left. Missed my last chance to fill a spot when Bill finally peaced, so Astrid invited themself and I'm still nowhere closer to having Julian, Coco, and Lucky. Cherry, my other settle, has been a pleasant surprise though! Almost settled for Hopper yesterday, but he was originally my backup dreamy to Aurora and I got her first so I'm set on penguins. Kidd was my other "maybe I will" yesterday, but I already have Sherb, and he is perfect.