MadLucas
Well-Known Member
I was planning on letting you guys rule guesses out, but because of Swans recent history, I wouldn't choose something as controversial as this.
First confirmed Not-It.
Needles & Grooves AotM /// Vol. 28 - October 2021 /// Blonde Redhead - Melody of Certain Damaged Lemons
- Thread starter MadLucas
- Start date
I was planning on letting you guys rule guesses out, but because of Swans recent history, I wouldn't choose something as controversial as this.
First confirmed Not-It.
Completely understandable
Some people, even those who legit do condemn artists for the awful behavior and boycott, have still supported swans because they are an artist that if sorry hard to find a replacement for compared to say.. Brand New or Kodak Black
This also means that none of the members have had a problematic past.. so no ace of base because one member is/was a nazi
Last edited:
avecigrec
Well-Known Member
MadLucas
Well-Known Member
Clue recap:
1. Two people in the band were dating when the record was made (note I didn't say if they still were or not)
2. It was the band's fifth album
Next clue in the next day or two... let's see what else you come up with!
1. Two people in the band were dating when the record was made (note I didn't say if they still were or not)
2. It was the band's fifth album
Next clue in the next day or two... let's see what else you come up with!
AC Slaughter
Active Member
Since the next clue is their 5th album should this be amended to Sister? Im going off Allmusic but that is what they are showing for their 5th album.
MadLucas
Well-Known Member
This is where it gets weird, as some people count the Sonic Youth LP as an album, some as an EP. I'll put you down for Sister, though, if you want!
you also have implied they have not had a huge problematic moment that can hurt the listening of them
MadLucas
Well-Known Member
I didn't realize that was a clue, but I'll take it!
It does make me uncomfortable to think about how many bands would get weeded out there.
AC Slaughter
Active Member
I would feel bad snaking that guess.
Put me down for Siouxsie and the Banshees A Kiss in Dreamhouse.
MadLucas
Well-Known Member
I will drop my next actual hint on Monday.
In the meantime, I am willing to answer questions.
In the meantime, I am willing to answer questions.
ThePakoBuelna
Well-Known Member
MadLucas
Well-Known Member
Day is *meh* but I am home now so it's looking up
As far as a "classic" album... This probably weeds a few guesses out, but I think the album is more accepted as "well regarded."
And for your last question, huh?
TenderLovingKiller®
Well-Known Member
A 90s album?
MadLucas
Well-Known Member
A band that started and bubbled on the underground circuit in the 90's, but this album is from the 00's.
MadLucas
Well-Known Member
When I started this, I was CONVINCED someone would have gotten this by now...
...and I just realized that, 3 official clues and 2 unofficial clues in, I have inadvertently with this last hint completely ruled out every single guess.
Should I go easier or stay on this trajectory?
avecigrec
Well-Known Member
I think you're doing great!
NewsFedora
Well-Known Member
You got 27 days left! I think you're doing fine!