Rank The Albums!

After lurking for a while, I decided to give this a shot:

Pixies:

Doolittle
Surfer Rosa
Bossanova
Trompe Le Monde
Beneath the Eyrie
Head Carrier
Indie Cindy

Their first 3 albums are interchangeable, Beneath the Eyrie is the most passable of the second run.
I'd rank the Come on Pilgrim EP near the top.
 
I'm newer to the forum (early 2021), so I'm not sure if some of these discographies have been ranked into the ground or not. Regardless, I'm going to start sharing some of my rankings here 👌

Porcupine Tree

1. In Absentia (2002)
2. Fear Of A Blank Planet (2007)
3. Deadwing (2005)
4. Stupid Dream (1999)
5. Lightbulb Sun (2000)
6. Signify (1996)
7. The Incident (2009)
8. Up The Downstair (1993)
9. The Sky Moves Sideways (1995)
10. On The Sunday Life... (1992)
 
Last edited:
Opeth

1. Still Life (1999)
2. Blackwater Park (2001)
3. In Cauda Venenum (2019)
4. My Arms, Your Hearse (1998)
5. Watershed (2008)
6. Ghost Reveries (2005)
7. Morningrise (1996)
8. Orchid (1995)
9. Pale Communion (2014)
10. Sorceress (2016)
11. Damnation (2003)
12. Deliverance (2002)
13. Heritage (2011)
 
a few I've been thinking about recently...

Japanese Breakfast
  1. Jubilee
  2. Psychopomp
  3. Soft Sounds From Another Planet
Fleet Foxes
  1. Helplessness Blues
  2. Fleet Foxes
  3. Crack-Up
  4. Shore
St. Vincent
  1. Strange Mercy
  2. Actor
  3. St. Vincent
  4. Marry Me
  5. Daddy's Home
  6. MASSEDUCATION
 
Julia Holter*

1. Aviary (2018)
2. Have You In My Wilderness (2015)
3. Loud City Song (2013)
4. Ekstasis (2012)
5. Tragedy (2011)

*one of the very few artists who has improved with each subsequent release
 
wokeupnew said:
It's an 8/10 album but someone has to be at the bottom. I was thinking it's unfair to put it there because it's not bad at all. Crack-Up is about a 8.5, the first two are almost perfect 10s IMO.
Click to expand...
That's the beauty of music 👌 Regardless, FF surely has one of the strongest discographies
 
I'll also do this here, since I've been listening to them a bit recently.

GREEN DAY:

1. American Idiot
2. Dookie
3. Nimrod
4. Insomniac
5. 21st Century Breakdown - Honestly, this one is pretty good don't know why people trash it so hard...
6. Warning
7. Revolution Radio
8. Dos
9. Uno
10. Tre
11. Father Of All... :sick::sick:
 
Last edited:
yukbon said:
Metallica
  1. Master of Puppets
  2. ...And Justice for All
  3. Garage Days Inc
  4. Ride The Lightning
  5. Kill 'Em All
  6. Death Magnetic
  7. Metallica (Black album)
  8. Hardwired
Click to expand...
Load, Relaod, & Some Kind of Monster? Metallica was my favorite band as a kid. Here's mine:

Metallica

1. Justice
2. Puppets
3. Lightning
4. Black
5. Kill
6. Load
7. Reload
8. Garage
9. Hardwired
10. Magnetic
11. Monster
 
tonythegamer said:
I'll also do this here, since I've been listening to them a bit recently.

GREEN DAY:

1. American Idiot
2. Dookie
3. Nimrod
4. Insomniac
5. 21st Century Breakdown
6. Warning
7. Revolution Radio
8. Dos
9. Uno
10. Tre
11. Father Of All... :sick::sick:
Click to expand...
Every year I do a "worst albums" list. 2020's worst was, well, you know... 🤢🤢
 
musicjunkiegreg said:
Fiona Apple

1. Fetch The Bolt Cutters (2020)
2. The Idler Wheel... (2012)
3. Tidal (1996)
4. When The Pawn (1999)
5. Extraordinary Machine (2005)
Click to expand...
This made me realize that Fiona Apple is tough to rank. I’d probably go...

1. When the Pawn
2. Fetch the Bolt Cutters
3. Extraordinary Machine
4. The Idler Wheel
5. Tidal

... but I don’t feel good about it.
 
bettim84 said:
This made me realize that Fiona Apple is tough to rank. I’d probably go...

1. When the Pawn
2. Fetch the Bolt Cutters
3. Extraordinary Machine
4. The Idler Wheel
5. Tidal

... but I don’t feel good about it.
Click to expand...
I KNOOOOOOW.. I would argue that she is one of few artists who has a damn near flawless discography.
 
musicjunkiegreg said:
Load, Relaod, & Some Kind of Monster? Metallica was my favorite band as a kid. Here's mine:

Metallica

1. Justice
2. Puppets
3. Lightning
4. Black
5. Kill
6. Load
7. Reload
8. Garage
9. Hardwired
10. Magnetic
11. Monster
Click to expand...
1. Master
2. Lightning
3. Justice
4. Kill em all
5. S&M - bonus!
6. Black Album
7. Hardwired
8. Garage Inc
9. Magnetic
10. S&M 2
11. Load/Reload, since they're both near identical to me
12. Monster
 
musicjunkiegreg said:
Load, Relaod, & Some Kind of Monster? Metallica was my favorite band as a kid. Here's mine:

Metallica

1. Justice
2. Puppets
3. Lightning
4. Black
5. Kill
6. Load
7. Reload
8. Garage
9. Hardwired
10. Magnetic
11. Monster
Click to expand...

1. Master of Puppets
2. Ride the Lightning
3. Kill’Em All
.
.
.
4. ... And Justice for All
5. “Until It Sleeps”
6. About half of the Black Album
.
.
.
7. Death Magnetic
.
.
.
8. The drum sound on St. Anger
.
.
.
9. “Unforgiven II” or “Unforgiven III,” not really sure which is which
.
.
.
10. The muddy production of S&M
.
.
.
11. “Turn the Page”

#8-11 are interchangeable.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top