TrainFan73
Frothy
Were you aware that you @‘d yourself?
N&G Favourite DRUMMER of All Time
- Thread starter avecigrec
- Start date
avecigrec
Well-Known Member
avecigrec
Well-Known Member
Before we get to the results (which I'm still tallying), I just want to take a second to thank all of y'all who participated in this little thought exercise - I'm pretty floored by both the response and the results!
- 166 unique drummers received votes.
- Jon Bonham received the most individual votes... but will he receive the highest tally?!
Yer Ol' Uncle D
Well-Known Member
If your next list is favorite cowbell player, I'm done...
Gene Frenkel - 100 points
Gene Frenkel - 100 points
avecigrec
Well-Known Member
RESULTS!
The nerds of Needles & Grooves have spoken...
01. Neil Peart {108 pts}
02. John Bonham {102.5 pts}
03. Stewart Copeland {75 pts}
04. Keith Moon {66.25 pts}
04. Jimmy Chamberlin {66.25 pts}
06. Danny Carey {63 pts}
07. Dave Grohl {62 pts}
07. Tony Williams {62 pts}
09. Bill Bruford {55 pts}
10. Phil Collins {54.25 pts}
11. Art Blakey {50 pts}
12. Jaki Liebezeit {48 pts}
12. Tony Allen {48 pts}
14. Clyde Stubblefield {45.25 pts}
15. Questlove {45 pts}
15. Janet Weiss {45 pts}
17. Charlie Watts (42.25 pts}
18. Karen Carpenter {40 pts}
18. Levon Helm {40 pts}
20. Elvin Jones {38.25 pts}
The nerds of Needles & Grooves have spoken...
TOP 20 FAVOURITE DRUMMERS
01. Neil Peart {108 pts}
02. John Bonham {102.5 pts}
03. Stewart Copeland {75 pts}
04. Keith Moon {66.25 pts}
04. Jimmy Chamberlin {66.25 pts}
06. Danny Carey {63 pts}
07. Dave Grohl {62 pts}
07. Tony Williams {62 pts}
09. Bill Bruford {55 pts}
10. Phil Collins {54.25 pts}
11. Art Blakey {50 pts}
12. Jaki Liebezeit {48 pts}
12. Tony Allen {48 pts}
14. Clyde Stubblefield {45.25 pts}
15. Questlove {45 pts}
15. Janet Weiss {45 pts}
17. Charlie Watts (42.25 pts}
18. Karen Carpenter {40 pts}
18. Levon Helm {40 pts}
20. Elvin Jones {38.25 pts}
TenderLovingKiller®
Well-Known Member
Thanks for doing this. It’s been fun to follow.
Thackeraye
Well-Known Member
Great list. Thanks for organising! Todd Trainer must be just outside the top 20!
jamieanderson1968
Well-Known Member
I have proof Phil Collins bribed his way into the top 10!!!
TrainFan73
Frothy
N&G Favourite BASSIST of All Time
Round 1 - Drummers ROUND 2 - Let's keep it in the rhythm section! We'll do this MEGALIST style... Everyone has 100 points to distribute to their favorite drummers of all time. a) The most points you can give to a single drummer is 20 points. b) You must use all 100 points. c) Please organize...
www.needlesandgrooves.com
jamieanderson1968
Well-Known Member
Key-tarists!!
avecigrec
Well-Known Member
Herbie.
Holdsworthian
Active Member
Corea for me!
Holdsworthian
Active Member
Thanks for doing this. I hemmed and hawed but couldn't make up my mind so I didn't end up submitting. I mean, my damn list had 40 players on it!
Psymon
Active Member
I was going to say Jacobim Mugatu, but I misremembered - he didn’t play the keytar; he invented the piano key necktie.
Futureman!
But tbh, I always wanted the Flecktones to get a trad kit drummer.