I disagree with this statement. SK has been together for what, 25 years? It would take an awful lot for one person to come in and break that up in a year or two. I think that’s giving St. V too much power in the situation.
That would be like leaving a long term career job just because you got stuck working on one project that really wasn’t your thing. Let’s also not forget that Janet chose to stay through the recording process of the album, and even performed with them just a week or so ago.
I’m not a long term SK fan, I knew very little about them up until they came up in the forums. But just looking at a major decision like that from the outside, it seems clear things have been building for a long time, and it involves more than the sound. If it was just the sound or just St. V, Janet would have left during production. I think the fact that Janet has worked with other bands in the past, and this band has taken a long break in the past is telling. Not to mention the timing of the announcement is very vengeful and unprofessional. These are career musicians, not angsty teens. Janet knew exactly what she was doing with this timing. A lot things need to go wrong over time for things to build up to something like this.
I’m not saying St. V wasn’t a factor, but to blame her as the primary reason seems short sighted and overlooking the reality of complicated long term group endeavors.