Vinyl Me Please Essentials

VMPKJ said:
Says Kevin Gray is mastering from Highest quality digital
Click to expand...
Thanks! I wish they would hire someone who knew that is 10x more important that the fact that it is 180g or the first official u.s. press. I know Storf has a hard time understanding, but some people who collect records think the sound quality is the most important part of the pressing.
 
dhodo said:
Thanks! I wish they would hire someone who knew that is 10x more important that the fact that it is 180g or the first official u.s. press. I know Storf has a hard time understanding, but some people who collect records think the sound quality is the most important part of the pressing.
Click to expand...
It’s crazy that this isn’t number one for most vinyl collectors.
 
Dark Star Boogie said:
It’s crazy that this isn’t number one for most vinyl collectors.
Click to expand...
I'm not entirely sure when I first started collecting that I knew any better. A lot of times I assumed "oh it's on vinyl, it's supposed to sound better that way!" Even now, there are albums that I know were recorded digitally that I could just buy a FLAC or WAV file of and the sound difference wouldn't be all that different, but I still buy the vinyl. In the case of the Jorge Ben, I think they figured that most VMP members would be amped about it being available in the US for the first time. Plus, I assume the majority of VMP members do not even ask about the source and accept that it says "from the highest possible quality source".
 
MikeH said:
Even now, there are albums that I know were recorded digitally that I could just buy a FLAC or WAV file of and the sound difference wouldn't be all that different, but I still buy the vinyl.
Click to expand...
I do the same, but, although I haven't done much A/Bing myself, I've seen quite a few reports of there being considerably more compression applied to the digital releases than to the vinyl mastering for whatever reason. Definitely not always the case though.
 
MikeH said:
I'm not entirely sure when I first started collecting that I knew any better. A lot of times I assumed "oh it's on vinyl, it's supposed to sound better that way!" Even now, there are albums that I know were recorded digitally that I could just buy a FLAC or WAV file of and the sound difference wouldn't be all that different, but I still buy the vinyl. In the case of the Jorge Ben, I think they figured that most VMP members would be amped about it being available in the US for the first time. Plus, I assume the majority of VMP members do not even ask about the source and accept that it says "from the highest possible quality source".
Click to expand...
Absolutely agree, and a few years ago I was clueless on all of this so I wasn’t trying to throw shade on anyone who doesn’t think about sound quality as number one. My apologies if that came off sort of belittleing. My bad.
 
Dark Star Boogie said:
Absolutely agree, and a few years ago I was clueless on all of this so I wasn’t trying to throw shade on anyone who doesn’t think about sound quality as number one. My apologies if that came off sort of belittleing. My bad.
Click to expand...
I'll only belittling Storf, nobody else! Seriously though, not trying to come off as judgmental to people who don't prioritize that. Just ranting about the people who do prioritize it being frequently ignored by the marketing of VMP. They do seem to be doing better lately, but the inconsistencies are always frustrating.
 
Dark Star Boogie said:
Absolutely agree, and a few years ago I was clueless on all of this so I wasn’t trying to throw shade on anyone who doesn’t think about sound quality as number one. My apologies if that came off sort of belittleing. My bad.
Click to expand...
Oh I didn't read it like that. I just remember a simpler time when I didn't drop $60+ on MM Blue Note pressings haha. Looking back, I wish I had known all of that stuff sooner though because there are a lot of things I now own that I wouldn't have spend the money on necessarily.
 
MikeH said:
A lot of times I assumed "oh it's on vinyl, it's supposed to sound better that way!" Even now, there are albums that I know were recorded digitally that I could just buy a FLAC or WAV file of and the sound difference wouldn't be all that different, but I still buy the vinyl.
Click to expand...
In my experience, digital vs vinyl is a total crap shoot unless you're doing your homework. I don't always do mine, but I do seek out specific pressings of certain things. But honestly I love getting things for the record store, and sometimes I just jump on things because I like the album, or even just the album art. Like the old days of going to CD Warehouse with the family.

But seriously, just like sometimes the vinyl is better, sometimes the digital is better. It all depends on the mastering of the specific release.
For examples: Portugal. The Man - Woodstock and the new Claypool/Lennon album, both of those have MUCH better digital masters. Tool's picture disk of Lateralus is another example.

But then VMP's master of Fiona is miles better. And several releases from Analog Productions and Mofi. It's all about who's doing the master and the press.

And on the same topic... I have a few albums on vinyl, CD and streaming. - not all digital is the same either. It's ALL down to that specific release you are pulling.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top