Glad I'm not finding anything to swap for because....
So they got me back with the 3 for 2 promo (I know, how dumb can I be? *hangs head in shame*)
Elli got back to me and said that they made the swap on my essentials track manually but, now I can't even see my membership details page to confirm it....
EDIT: page is loading again and the swap is there (Bella Donna for Party Down).
EDIT 2: I've disabled the automatic renewal, I'm out after The White Stripes.