Needles & Grooves

File a claim with your credit card/form of payment.

@Melt Face Molly Drop Yeah but I'd rather not go that route, not going after the independent store I bought it from. It's also very, very far away from me distance wise right now. Sleeve looks great - was definitely a problem in production. Definitely labels fault, not the stores.

Did you buy it online or in a physical store? If the latter, just bring it back. I've never had an issue returning a defective record. They'll probably just return it to their distributor.

I thought you meant you bought it online. Then what @BjorgenFjorgen said. Either take it back or call them and explain the situation and have them contact the distributor. No point in you jumping through hoops for a defective product. The record store won't lose money.