A little bit of everything, but the score gets influenced when I like the album too much lol. I rate mainly the pressing soundwise, because many times the extra items or cover are damaged in a way or maybe even missing.
Needles & Grooves
ThePakoBuelna
BjorgenFjorgen
I don't really do it but I would rate only the pressing, packaging, etc. I go to Discogs for record info, not music reviews.
kvetcha
The quality of the mastering and pressing, mostly.
Melt Face Molly Drop
The pressing quality. Rate the digital or CD version if you're looking to review the music.
TCell
Hmm...that makes sense. I just find it weird to rank an album 5 stars because the sound quality is great, if I don't think the music matches that. (Lots of VMP Classics come to mind). Was mainly curious as I'm taking a mental health day, and listening to a backlog of records and updating my discogs.