Needles & Grooves

You're being too kind. If I ordered 4 records from a store or label and they wanted me to pay for or send back one they sent me by accident, I'd probably never order from them again. It's most likely just a freebie for being a good customer, but if not it's their mistake and any customer service worth its salt would just let you keep it. No online store should give you an errand.

I've gotten free records a couple times. Por ejemplo, cancelled a pre-order (the Chance the Rapper albums) and got refunded, months later still got them. I didn't return them and didn't blink an eye. Sold one of them and gave the other two away for free to members here who missed out. Didn't blink an eye. Was I morally wrong? Probably. Am I going to burn in hell? Definitely. Do I care? Not a bit.

@sahomerrocks Agreed. Very well said.

I got a free Doja Cat album from Target with my Lee Morgan Sidewinder BN80, best believe I took it right to my local for trade in credit. Hehehehe

literally the only company i have ever seen ask buyers to return something they were mistakenly sent is vinyl me, please.

Yeah, you're under no legal or moral obligation to notify them or send it back.

What @AndySlash said.

If you want a clear conscience, let them know you had an extra record in your shipment and I'll bet there's a 99.9% chance they'll say what a good person you are for letting them know and enjoy the free record.

@AndySlash yyyyyyep