In seems most logical. But its also a pain to get them out when you want to listen to them. I feel like they stand a better chance of spins if they're easily accessible.
@dbarila ngl, i had the same situation as you with the RTJ box, so i understand how you feel. it's a bit annoying pulling out the entire box set just for one album, but eh i still say put all of them in the box set.
I keep them in the box, and have all the box sets out beside my shelves rather than on the shelves. Also I have that Bright Eyes box and highly recommend it. It’s fantastic
In the box. I mean, it's a box set for Chrissakes. Getting out the box and digging in is part of the special vinyl experience we're all assumedly here for.