Rank The Albums!

wokeupnew said:
:unsure:


FIOE is prob my 2nd favorite Strokes album even though I know there's a lot of filler.
Click to expand...
It was the first one I heard all the way through (I know that’s crazy but I was late to them). But I just don’t enjoy so much of it that I never play it all the way through 🤷🏻‍♂️
 
whatwhatsaywhat said:
wilco: yankee hotel foxtrot > summerteeth > a ghost is born > being there > the whole love > star wars > ode to joy > schmilco > sky blue sky > am > wilco (the album)
Click to expand...
Gotta update this one from 2019:

The Commish said:
Well, now that we’re talking Wilco...
1. YHF
2. Summerteeth
3. Being There
4. Shmilco
5. A Ghost is Born
6. Wilco (The Album)
7 A.M.
8. Star Wars
9. The Whole Love
10. Sky Blue Sky
Click to expand...

1.YHF
2. Summerteeth
3. Being There
4. Shmilco
5. A Ghost is Born
6. Ode To Joy
7. Star Wars
8. A.M.
8. Wilco (The Album)
9. The Whole Love
10. Sky Blue Sky
 
From the MMJ Thread:
The Commish said:
1. Evil Urges
2. Z
3. It Still Moves
4. Circuital
5. At Dawn
6. Okonokos
7. The Waterfall
8. The Waterfall ll
9. Songs/Ohia Split
10. The Tennessee Fire
11. X-mas Fiasco Style
12. Chapter 1/Chapter 2: Early recordings, B-sides and Covers
13. Chocolate and Ice
Click to expand...
 
Rank the Albums: Christian Rock Legends Edition

Skillet
1. Collide
2. Comatose
3. Alien Youth
4. Invincible
5. Skillet
6. Rise
7. Hey You, I Love Your Soul
8. Unleashed
9. Victorious
10. Awake

Red
1. Of Beauty And Rage
2. End Of Silence
3. Declaration
4. Gone
5. Innocence & Instinct
6. Until We Have Faces
7. Release The Panic

Flyleaf
1. Memento Mori
2. Flyleaf
3. New Horizons
4. Between The Stars
 
I think this would be my Blur ranking, I've honestly never put much thought into how I'd rank their albums tbh 🤔
  1. 13
  2. The Magic Whip
  3. The Great Escape
  4. Modern Life is Rubbish
  5. Parklife
  6. Think Tank
  7. Blur
  8. Leisure
I should probably go back and listen to all of them and then re-do this list, because this seems... off.
 
gaporter said:
I think this would be my Blur ranking, I've honestly never put much thought into how I'd rank their albums tbh 🤔
  1. 13
  2. The Magic Whip
  3. The Great Escape
  4. Modern Life is Rubbish
  5. Parklife
  6. Think Tank
  7. Blur
  8. Leisure
I should probably go back and listen to all of them and then re-do this list, because this seems... off.
Click to expand...

That sure is different! The Great Escape being higher than Modern Life is Rubbish or Parklife seems like a pretty hot take from here lol. But maybe that’s a different perspective from being that bit younger and finding them after the fact rather than being around as they came out?
 
Joe Mac said:
That sure is different! The Great Escape being higher than Modern Life is Rubbish or Parklife seems like a pretty hot take from here lol. But maybe that’s a different perspective from being that big younger and finding them after the fact rather than being around as they came out?
Click to expand...
Yeah, I guess at the time The Great Escape was kind of seen as a lesser retread of Parklife but I think it has the stronger highs of the two for me personally, although Parklife is probably more consistent in its quality. As for MLIR, I don't listen to that one as much as the others, so it's hard to rank it with the others, which is why I should probably try to do another ranking with a fresh listen through
 
gaporter said:
Yeah, I guess at the time The Great Escape was kind of seen as a lesser retread of Parklife but I think it has the stronger highs of the two for me personally, although Parklife is probably more consistent in its quality. As for MLIR, I don't listen to that one as much as the others, so it's hard to rank it with the others, which is why I should probably I should try to do another ranking with a fresh listen through
Click to expand...

My issue with The Great Escape is that I always found that blur’s most annoying trend was that their caricatures could tend towards obnoxious and felt that several songs on that album were full on obnoxious (Stereotypes and Country House in particular) and the mastering on it is pretty poor, it’s bad brickwalling, oh so very loud! The only song I’d save off it is The Universal, which is immense.

I disagree with you on Parklife, I think it’s inconsistent at times but Girls and Boys, End of a Century, the title track and, in particular, the epic This Is A Low, are better for me than anything The Great Escape,

That said out of the English trio Modern Life Is Rubbish absolutely smokes both for me in terms of song quality and consistency!
 
Joe Mac said:
My issue with The Great Escape is that I always found that blur’s most annoying trend was that their caricatures could tend towards obnoxious and felt that several songs on that album were full on obnoxious (Stereotypes and Country House in particular) and the mastering on it is pretty poor, it’s bad brickwalling, oh so very loud! The only song I’d save off it is The Universal, which is immense.

I disagree with you on Parklife, I think it’s inconsistent at times but Girls and Boys, End of a Century, the title track and, in particular, the epic This Is A Low, are better for me than anything The Great Escape,

That said out of the English trio Modern Life Is Rubbish absolutely smokes both for me in terms of song quality and consistency!
[/QUOTE
Don’t forget He Thought of Cars. One of my favorites!
Click to expand...
 
Bluecloud777 said:
Blur

1. Modern life is rubbish
2. 13
3. Blur
4. Leisure
5. The Great Escape
6. The Magic Whip
7. Parklife
8. Think Tank


Oasis

1. (What's the story) Morning glory
2. Definitely maybe
3. The Masterplan
4. Be here now
5. Don't believe the truth
6. Standing on the shoulder of giants
7. Heathen chemistry
8. Dig out your soul
Click to expand...
Blur:

1. Parklife
2. Modern Life Is Rubbish
3. Blur
4. 13
5. The Great Escape
6. The Magic Whip
7. Think Tank
8. Leisure

Oasis:
1. Definitely Maybe
2. What's The Story
3. The Masterplan (not a proper album, but you ranked it)
4. Don't Believe The Truth
5. Standing On The Shoulder
6. Be Here Now
7. Dig Out Your Soul
8. Heathen Chemistry
 
I’m shocked to see 2 lists of oasis where the deplorable standing on the shoulder (just the one Noel?)of giants Isn’t dead last, kind of flabbergasting considering it has such turds as Little James and I Can See a Liar and one of the most boring songs of all time in Where Did It All Go Wrong? Noel’s “what the fuck was I thinking releasing this shit” audio commentary over the best of DVD is priceless.
 
Joe Mac said:
I’m shocked to see 2 lists of oasis where the deplorable standing on the shoulder (just the one Noel?)of giants Isn’t dead last, kind of flabbergasting considering it has such turds as Little James and I Can See a Liar and one of the most boring songs of all time in Where Did It All Go Wrong? Noel’s “what the fuck was I thinking releasing this shit” audio commentary over the best of DVD is priceless.
Click to expand...

I revisited it lately and it wasn’t as bad as I remembered it, but it does have several of the worst oasis songs. Better high points than Heathen
 
McGlam said:
I revisited it lately and it wasn’t as bad as I remembered it, but it does have several of the worst oasis songs. Better high points than Heathen
Click to expand...

Nah, The Hindu Times for one smokes anything on Shoulder. Go Let It Out is the only song I’d save off it and that’s pretty much a worse retread of Roll With It which was always their worst early period single. Also that tour was the worst I saw them live too, for a band that was always better live they were dogshit on the shoulder tour. Don’t Believe The Truth is probably my favourite late period oasis album and The Importance of Being Idle is probably my favourite late period oasis song.
 
Gallagher’s After Oasis

Who Sold The Moon?
Noel Gallagher’s High Flying Birds
As You Were
Why Me? Why Not.
Chasing Yesterday
Different Gear Still Speeding
BE (the worst album that I own, comically bad)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top