Most people feel “Monster” was where the band jumped the shark, sold out or whatever. Maybe…but I’m still a fan of that album. And I think “New Adventures” is their best record.
I did this a few years ago but couldn't really scratch the surface beyond the singles. Outside of a few albums their singles always felt like singles and everything else mostly felt like filler. Reckoning is their best album IMO.
They snuck up on me. I became aware of them during the “Losing My Religion” era but didn’t really begin to follow them as a band until Automatic For The People and it wouldn’t be until much later that I would work back through a deep dive of their earlier work, after learning that they were basically The Michael Jordan of Underground Rock.
It's a really fun journey. I was always aware of REM growing up, but I never took the time to listen to them deeply until I was much older. I went through all their albums in random order and found so much to love. I still think Murmur is my favorite even though it doesn't sound like most of their catalog. But New Adventures in Hi-Fi is great, as is Document. Those three might be my favorites overall.