Big spike in car prices and post-COVID driving being kinda nutty plays into it too...but shop it around. Progressive, Metlife, etc. Might be worth contacting na agent.
I had Geico for the longest time and they were great and cheap. But then I got a new car and their quote was crazy high, so I moved to Progressive. No problems so far.
State Farm also majorly shafted home policy owners here in SE LA after Ida. They were finding any reason to not pay and when they did pay, they gave some of the lowest payouts.
I'm on progressive too. It's literally half the price of anyone else I've gotten quotes from. But it's still more than I'd like to pay for having clean driving records.