I’d go with @BjorgenFjorgen or Fevers and Mirrors. I’m Wide Awake didn’t get great reviews (compared to their other records) for some reason, but I love that album.
VINYL BOX SET FEATURES: Limited Edition of 5000 Worldwide 5 classic albums REMASTERED by Bob Ludwig (+ The People’s Key, originally mastered by Bob Ludwig) 6 albums on 10 LPs Pressed at RTI COLORED VINYL for all 6 releases exclusive to this box set Foil stamped linen wrapped box Twelve 8x10...
'Fevers and mirrors' and 'lifted' are my 2 favorite, but would recommend 'Im Wide Awake, Its Morning' first for you. Much more alt-country, and emmylou harris features, and probably most accessible. Should be up your alley. Glad you like the new one too; I think it's great.