I spammed them everywhere hah. Posted on instagram comments, DMed them on instagram, etc. Talked with someone on instagram who told me that they would reach out to CS on my behalf. 4 days later (granted it was over the weekend) I got a shipping notification from VMP and they sent me a quick email to say they sent a replacement and sorry for delay...good luck!
Chiming in again. Got two damaged records yesterday. Emailed them today and got a response that replacements were on the way in 4 hours. It really is a crapshoot.