I like the loose, off-the-cuff feel of the record, and I think there are a couple of really good tracks sprinkled in throughout. That said, I do think we are getting some serious knee jerk reactions right now. Or maybe I'm just more of a casual fan than most.
That's all good. And you know it's a great album when even the dissenting opinions want to be heard. It happens every time something is praised this highly.
"This thing a lot of people love is overpraised" is rarely a great take. Not that I think Pitchfork's ratings mean anything ever, but just because art doesn't speak to YOU doesn't make it a less-good thing.