Update: Found someone on Twitter who experienced the same error so I replied to them. Then the Matador Records account replied to us both and said to email them my info and they’d send me a fresh copy. So that’s cool.
I kinda thought that had happened and that it was a super weird joke I didn’t get, but then I saw someone else post photos of their record and it looked correct.
Got home, opened up Spoon and…
Whoops. Called the record store and their last copy was wrong too (he opened it while on the phone). He’s gotta call his distributor and get replacements. Sincerely hope he can.
The originals are on Spotify too, and have been for years, but I assumed that these albums (and the EP) will be getting remasters that would show up on digital platforms too. I might be misunderstanding the announcement.