I love Modest Mouse! My favorite album of theirs is definitely The Moon and Antarctica, but if I had to pick a favorite track... hmmm... maybe "Styrofoam Boots/It's All Nice on Ice Alright." Ah, when those drums kick in...
+1 on Moon & Antarctica. Think it’s the right middle ground of frenetic guitar work/manic vocals of early work and refinement of later (cf Good News...) work. But...non-objectively the song I like is Never Ending Math Equation
Good News For People Who Love Bad News was the CD I used to audition B&W speakers when we were buying a pair for our new home in the summer of 04. I'm still chasing the sound those B&Ws made at the audio shop.
Wait, is this something to be ashamed of? Maybe if your favorite album is the last one?
Lonesome Crowded West is my favorite followed closely by Moon in Antarctica and This is a Long Drive..., hard for me to pick between those two. Good news is really good too.