Needles & Grooves

Group consensus ranking was: Double Stuf, classic Oreo, Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, Golden Double Stuf, Peanut Butter, Mint, Carrot Cake, Dark Chocolate, Salted Caramel Brownie, Java Chip, Caramel Coconut, Team USA, Birthday Cake, Chocolate Marshmallow, Mega Stuf, Chocolate Hazelnut.

The most controversial varieties were Carrot Cake (if you don't like nutmeg, you won't enjoy it), Mint, and Java Chip.

Whats so mad about mega stuf? Edit: Nevermind, just looked at a picture.....good god!

I must say I was pleasantly surprised by the Carrot Cake, tried it a few weeks back. It was actually pretty good.

@DJSJ the creme filling actually tastes different in those, too. More chemical-y and artificial. That was the main reason for the low score. Double stuf and classic oreos seem to use the exact same tasting creme filling but those mega stuf oreos must have a different recipe (maybe to help them hold their shape?).

Thank you for doing this important work!

I contest this chocolate hazelnut ranking, unless y’all just hate nutella.

@kvetcha I was just about post that this flavor must be a real abomination to earn such a low ranking. In theory that's a slam dunk(er) of a cookie.

@kvetcha I love nutella, but those oreos just tasted…off. You could tell what they were going for, but they didn’t make it all the way there.

Anything with coconut should be dead last.